February 18, 2026

Canned Butter...

Canned Butter

On Monday night, when Handsome was at band rehearsal, I did a thing. After a lot of research, I've learned that this process (while unapproved by FDA) is completely safe and has been safely done by the Amish and farm families for generations.

The butter is melted in a big pot while jars and lids are being heated. The melted butter is then ladled into the jars, rims cleaned (not with vinegar, which could cause the butter to curdle), rings tightly attached, and then back into the oven for another 20 minutes or so. Place the jars on the counter to cool. Once the lids have pinged, intermittently shake the jars to make sure the butter solids don't separate while they cool. Once cooled, label and store. The butter is perfectly shelf stable for at least two years.

When I purchase butter, I wait until it's on sale for less than $3/pound, and then I buy a case of it. I've always kept the extra in the freezer until I learned about this method. Now, I won't be taking up freezer space, and the butter is ready to use whenever I need it.

I used wide mouth jars, and filled them to leave 1" of headspace. Five pounds of butter yielded six pints, canned. It doesn't take that long to do either. I'd say it was a good use of an hour of the time Handsome was away, making great music.

8 comments:

  1. That's interesting.
    I never heard of that method.
    Marilyn

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Marilyn-
      I thought so, too. This frees up freezer space, plus, I don't have to wait for my butter to thaw. I'll let you know how it works out
      Hugs,
      xoxo
      Donna

      Delete
  2. I've never heard of canning butter either - interesting! I don't think I'll do it because butter here is really expensive. We rarely buy it and then only from the semi-local dairy, mainly done in an effort to support them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi MA-
      I wouldn't do it with Kerrygold ($7+ a pound), but this is our everyday butter and what I use for baking. I'm looking forward to seeing how this holds up. I think I'll open a jar in March, April, June, just to test it myself. I'll let you know.
      Hugs,
      xoxo
      Donna

      Delete
  3. Who knew?
    The Amish are amazing people.
    Shirley

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Shirley-
      The Amish AND our ancestors. They knew so much that can benefit us.
      Hugs,
      xoxo
      Donna

      Delete
  4. Sherryofcreateology: I have not heard of canning butter either. However…Why Not?! You dear are so resourceful. Your pantry must make preppers so jealous! Happy Canning…

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sherry-
      I only learned of it last year and just decided to give it a go. I learn so much from others, and likewise want to share. I guess I owe everyone photos of the pantry! I'll get on that.
      Hugs,
      xoxo
      Donna

      Delete

Thank you so much for leaving a comment today. I'm using new settings on my comments so that I'll be able to respond to your messages to me. Be sure to come back to see my replies!

Blessings, Donna